Select Page

Protect America vs ADT


Protect America vs ADT Monitored Security Comparison Review

With so many home security companies in the marketplace, choosing the best home security company to help protect your home and family can seem a bit overwhelming. If you’ve narrowed it down to an ADT Monitored Security System  and Protect America Security…you have selected a couple of our top rated alarm companies. In this Protect America vs ADT review, we’ll try to help you sort out which of these popular security companies works best for you.

This ADT Monitored Security vs Protect America Review  compares the most recognized  professionally installed home security company with our #2 rated company, Protect Americathe company that pioneered the professionally monitored Do It Yourself alarm industry.

In this head to head comparison of ADT Monitoring vs Protect America, we’ll examine some of the key differences between  two of the best home security companies of 2018….and see which one makes the most sense for your situation.

ADT Monitoring vs. Protect America 

About our Comparison Reviews 

In this comparative analysis, we  will explore the similarities and differences in 5 separate categories. For the purposes of this  review, each category is valued equally….but, you may assign a lessor or greater value, based on your needs.

You can jump ahead to a specific category or area of interest by clicking on any of the links to the left.

In the summary section we determine a “winner”  by tallying up the individual “rounds”, but your selection may vary depending on your priorities.


Protect America vs ADT Authorized Provider, Safe Streets

 2019 Comparison Review


Reputation and Credibility – Who to Trust?


ADT Monitored Security

Safe Streets  was founded in 1998 and is one of the largest Authorized Providers for ADT, the number one name in the home security industry.

They have earned an A+ BBB rating by providing exceptional installation and service to thousands of satisfied customers.

All monitoring services are provided by ADT , which was founded 140 years ago as American District Telegraph and is the oldest and most recognized name in home security.



Protect America

This 20+ year old company  pioneered the DIY wireless security industry and enjoys an A BBB rating. Protect America has been awarded the Consumer Digest Best Buy 5 times in recent years, and has consistently been in the top 15 companies on the SDM Top 100.


Reputation and Credibility

  • BBB Rating
  • Years in Business
  • SDM Top 100 Rank
  • Winner
    ADT Security Reviews -Safe Street Rectangular Logo
  • A+
  • 18+
  • #1
    Protect America Logo
  • A
  • 20+
  • #15

Protect America has a strong BBB rating which is indicative of the company’s ongoing commitment to customer satisfaction.
However, the ADT Authorized Provider systems are monitored by the #1  security company in the country- which  is tough to beat.

Both companies enjoy a favorable BBB rating, and extensive experience helping to protect homes, families and businesses but ADT Monitoring is practically synonymous with home security.

Their stronghold on the #1 position on the SDM Top 100 for over a decade can’t be overlooked….giving them the edge in the first category.

Back to Top

Monitoring Services

Both of these companies offer UL Listed, 5 Diamond Certified  monitoring. This means they meet the highest industry standards and provide 24/7 protection against intrusion, emergency and personal safety, fire and environmental hazards.

ADT operates a total of  6 monitoring stations across the country. This provides the highest level of redundancy in the event of a local emergency. (enabling calls to be rerouted to another command center in the event of a disaster in one area)

Monitoring rates run from $36.99-$58.99…..and are NOT guaranteed to remain the same after the first year.

Protect America provides excellent 3rd party monitoring through a network of 3 Criticomm command centers-offering similar redundancy. Their basic monitoring package is truly an exceptional value at $19.99….and their rates are  locked in for the life of the contract!

While both companies include about the same equipment in their basic packages, the Protect America premium services also include a substantial amount of additional equipment which can be tailored to meet individual needs.

Additionally, unlike the ADT monitoring services, which are only available to homeowners, Protect America makes all their packages available to renters as well.



  • Contract Term
  • Price Range
  • Redundancy
  • FREE Equipment Included?
  • Available to Renters
  • Locked In Rate?
  • Winner
    ADT Security Reviews -Safe Street Rectangular Logo
  • 3 Years
  • $36.99-$58.99+
  • 6 Monitoring Stations
    Protect America Logo
  • 3 Years
  • $20- $50+
  • 3 monitoring Stations

With substantially lower basic monitoring, premium packages that include additional equipment, and award winning services available to renters as well as homeowners….Protect America wins this round convincingly.

For a complete rundown of Protect America  and ADT monitoring services and pricing, check out individual reviews, at :

ADT Monitored Security Review

Protect America  Security Review

Back to Top

Customer Service – What happens after the sale?


ADT Monitored Customer Service

The ADT Authorized Provider has been providing security services and helping to protect  homes and businesses  for a long time. They have an outstanding A+ BBB rating, which they have earned by professionally  installing  home security systems that include the exclusive ADT 6 month service guarantee.  This states that ADT will resolve any service oriented issue within 6 months. This is not really a return policy like most of our best home security companies (i.e, Frontpoint, Protect America and Link Interactive) offer, but, it does state that if they can’t resolve any service related concerns that they will remove the equipment and refund your money. (certain restrictions apply)


Protect America Customer Service

With an A BBB rating, Protect America has a solid reputation and a 20+ year track record of providing superior customer service and installation tech support. This is an important consideration for a DIY security company. Simply put, the folks at Protect America know how to ensure a simple and seamless self installation….and how to keep their customers happy after the sale.

They even offer professional installation, for an additional cost, for those who are intimidated by the self installation process.  However, they pre-program the systems and have such outstanding  support that over 90% of their customers found the system easy to install.

Unlike most companies that offer a one or 2 year equipment warranty (or require a $50 minimum “truck roll” fee on their “extended warranties”), Protect America has a LIFETIME Warranty on their equipment.


Customer Service

  • BBB Rating
  • Experience
  • Return Policy
  • Equipment Warranty
  • Winner
    ADT Security Reviews -Safe Street Rectangular Logo
  • A+
  • 18+ Years
  • 3 Day RR
  • 3 Years
    Protect America Logo
  • A
  • 20+ Years
  • 14 Days /$79 Restock
  • Lifetime

While each of the  companies offer quality customer service and similar BBB rating, Protect America gets a slight edge over an ADT Monitored System in this department with their 14 Day Return Policy and Lifetime Warranty.

Back to Top

Equipment and Technology


ADT Monitored Security Equipment

ADT Monitored equipment is manufactured by leading equipment suppliers and is professionally installed by the ADT Authorized Provider.

 ADT Security SystemThey offer a comprehensive equipment lineup to satisfy the needs of virtually any security situation.  They have basic  home security systems and ADT Pulse® for more sophisticated interactive home automation and third party energy management applications.

Because they are using brand named equipment by some of the most trusted names in the industry, ADT monitored systems include the exclusive  ADT  6 Month Service Guarantee (certain restrictions apply).


Package pricing and the brand manufacturer often varies.   However,  the basic package pricing is usually competitive and carries the  ADT 6 Month Service Guarantee (certain restrictions apply).

In most areas, there is a tremendous selection of equipment available to meet virtually any security or home automation requirements.

However, even though advertised monitoring prices may start as low as $36.99, the equipment add ons, upgrades and monthly monitoring costs can add up very quickly as additional options are included.


Protect America Equipment and Costs


Protect America offers a wide variety of equipment packages that incorporate both the equipment and monitoring-with $0 up front costs.  The Control Panel that is included in all packages is the GE Simon XT, a tried, tested and proven panel which offers 40 zones of protection, a 100 event history buffer, voice annunciation and a 2-way voice intercom.

The basic Copper Package, a perennial Consumer Digest Best Buy winner,  is available for $0 Down and just $19.99/mo.All equipment is provided by GE and meets the highest industry quality standards.

Simon XTi Control Panel

Simon XTi Control Panel (with Optional Silver Template Cover)

They have recently introduced a new Touchscreen Control Panel- the GE Simon XTi.  This panel is available as an upgrade on the Silver, Gold and Platinum packages.

It has a touchscreen interface which is as easy to use as an i-phone and interchangeable face plates to match  interior decor.


Unique Interactive Technologies

Both companies offer some great advanced technologies to enhance their systems…

ADT Monitored Systems have:

  • ADT Pulse® Voice – Allows one to control basic functions through their ADT Pulse® App with voice commands


Protect America offers

  • GPS Vehicle Tracking- Plugs into the ODP port and allows you to monitor the speed and location of your vehicle on Google Maps. It can be programmed to notify you via e-mail or text if the vehicle travels beyond a prescribed area.



  • $0 Up front Pricing
  • Advanced Touchscreen Control Panel
  • Basic Home Automation
  • Multiple Video Camera Options
  • Winner
    ADT Security Reviews -Safe Street Rectangular Logo
    Protect America Logo


While Protect America represents an exceptional value with their $0 Down pricing policy, their equipment technology selections are a bit limited compared to an ADT Monitored System.


ADT Authorized  Provider – Safe Streets gets the nod in this round, by a slim margin, based on their wider selection of advanced equipment technology.


Back to Top

Price and Value – Best Bang for the Buck?


While the ADT Authorized Provider may offer reasonably competitive basic packages and rates, the ultimate costs may increase astronomically when it comes time to sign on the dotted line. Sure..the basic package may start at $99 for installation and as low as $36.99 for monitoring, but the prices may escalate quickly from there.

If you want their ADT Pulse interactive services (which enable you to control the system remotely through ADT’s  portal on your desktop or through an app on an Android or IOS mobile device), cellular monitoring or home automation capabilities- there will be significant increases in the monthly monitoring rates as well as substantial up front costs to install the additional equipment that is required.

Your monitoring rate can increase substantially …with advanced ADT monitoring packages running  58.99.

Equipment costs can skyrocket. Professionally installed components are often 1.5x to 3X as expensive as their DIY counterparts. For many, this may become cost prohibitive as more comprehensive custom systems quickly become substantially more expensive.

Protect America offers an incredible $0 Up Front Pricing Policy on 5 packages starting at just $19.99. Their basic package includes:

  • Simon XT Control PanelGE Simon XT
  • 3 Door/Window Sensors
  • 1 Motion Detector
  • 1 Yard Sign
  • 3 Window Stickers
  • Owners Manual
  • Lifetime Equipment Warranty


More comprehensive protection packages are available that can be fully customized to meet individual needs and preferences. All equipment is provided by GE and meets the highest industry quality standards.  Monthly monitoring rates range from $19.99-54.99 depending on the equipment package  and the monitoring services selected.


Price and Value

  • Up Front Costs
  • Entry Level Monitoring
  • Add On Sensors (Door/Window Contact)
  • Best Price Guarrantee
  • Lifetime Warranty
  • Best Price Guarantee
  • Winner
    ADT Security Reviews -Safe Street Rectangular Logo
  • $99+
  • $36.99
  • $129.00
    Protect America Logo
  • $0
  • $19.99
  • $49.00

In addition they offer a BEST PRICE Guarantee…making them the hands down winner in this category!

While ADT Authorized Provider – Safe Streets offers a competitive introductory program, with professional installation – Protect America wins this round decisively with their $0 up front equipment costs, substantially lower equipment and monthly monitoring rates…combined with a Best Price Guarantee and a Lifetime Warranty!!

Back to Top

ADT Monitored Security vs. Protect America – Security Review Summary


Both of these companies are among the best home security companies that you could select to help protect your home and family.

When it comes down to choosing between ADT  Monitoring and Protect America-it may come down to choosing between DIY and professional installation.

Some people will not feel comfortable unless even a wireless system is professionally installed. For those folks, we recommend that you inquire about Protect America’s professional installation option in your area.

For those who are on the fence, it is important to recognize that Protect America has streamlined the entire process so that the end user merely has to place the sensors and call in to activate.

Over 90% of all customers find the system easy to install…and ultimately become more familiar with the use, features, functions and capabilities of the system when they are involved in the set up.

And… for those who don’t want a stranger in the house and are willing to invest a few minutes to complete the process, there can be substantial savings and some benefits over an ADT Monitored Security System..

While they have a well deserved reputation for being THE #1 Name in the security business, ADT Monitoring is not the cheapest game in town….and Protect America offers an outstanding alternative for those looking for minimize up front costs and  save a bit of money.


Comparison Summary

  • Reputation and Credibility
  • Monitoring
  • Customer Service
  • Equipment and Technology
  • Price and Value
  • Winner
    ADT Security Reviews -Safe Street Rectangular Logo
    Protect America Logo

At the end of the day, we feel that Protect America  offers a better overall value for the majority of those looking for the best alarm company to protect their homes and family.


Find out more about Protect America

Find out more about ADT Monitoring

Back to Top


Leave a Reply

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.

Follow Us

How We Rank- Disclaimer

HSA How We Rank Home Security Companies A  

The rankings and ratings expressed on this site are the opinion of and are subject to change. To keep this valuable service free, we generate advertising revenue from the companies featured in our rankings.Disclosure: The Home Security Advisor participates in the Amazon Services LLC Associates Program, an affiliate advertising program designed to provide a means for publishers to earn fees by linking to and affiliated sites. Learn More.

Get Your FREE Security Guide!

Frontpoint reviews  Sum 9.5Frontpoint Security -More Info
Best Security Systems - Vivint Rank Rect.Vivint Security -More Info
Best Home Security Companies ADT-Safe Streets RatingADT Security -More Info
Top Alarm Companies -Link InteractiveLink Interactive Security -More Info
SimpliSafe Review Rating
Protect America Security -More Info

Protect Your Child From Predators!

Family Watchdog- logo

Learn More

Best Home Security Systems

Side by Side Comparisons of the Top Security Systems 

* FREE Security System
*$99 charge for parts & installation with monthly monitoring services. Termination Fee Applies. For New Customers Only. (See T&Cs Below)

ADT Terms and Conditions
*$99 Customer Installation Charge. 36-Month Monitoring Agreement required at $36.99 per month ($1,331.64), 24-Month Monitoring Agreement required at $36.99 ($887.76) for California, including Quality Service Plan (QSP). Form of payment must be by credit card or electronic charge to your checking or savings account. Offer applies to homeowners only. Certain packages require approved landline phone. Local permit fees may be required. Satisfactory credit history required. Termination Fee applies. Certain restrictions may apply. Offer valid for new ADT Authorized Premier Provider customers only and not on purchases from ADT LLC. Other rate plans available. Cannot be combined with any other offer.

Licenses: AL-17-1104, AK-35221, AZ-ROC217517, AR-2008-0014, CA-ACO6320, CT-ELC.0193944-L5, DE-07-212, FL-EC13003427, DC-602513000006, GA-LVA205395, HI-CT30946, ID-ELE-SC-39312, IL-127.001042, IN-City of Indianapolis: LAC-000156, IA-AC-0036, KY-City of Louisville: 483, LA-F1082, LA-F1914, LA-F1915, ME-LM50017382, MD-107-1626, MA-1355C, MI-3601205773, MN-TS01807, MS-15007958, MO-City of St. Louis: CC354, St. Louis County: 79853, MT-247, NE-14451, NV-68518, City of Las Vegas: 3000002944, NJ-34BF00021800, NM-353366, NY-Licensed by the N.Y.S. Dept. of State UID#12000317691, #12000286451, NC-1622-CSA, OH-53891446, City of Cincinnati: AC86, OK-1048, OR-170997, Pennsylvania Home Improvement Contractor Registration Number: PA22999, RI-3582, SC-BAC5630, SD-1025-7001-ET, TN-C1520, TX-B13734, ACR-3492, UT-6422596-6501, VT-ES-2382, VA-115120, WA-602588694/PROTEYH934RS, WV-042433, WI-City of Milwaukee: PAS-0002790, WY-LV-G-21499.

ADT Pulse
ADT Pulse Remote installation starts at $199. ADT Pulse Video installation starts at $399. ADT Pulse Home Control with Video installation starts at $499. Burglary, Fire, Carbon Monoxide and Emergency Alert monitoring requires purchase and/or activation of an ADT security system with monitored Burglary, Fire, Carbon Monoxide and Emergency Alert devices. Fire, Carbon Monoxide and Emergency Alert services are an additional charge. Quality Service Plan (QSP) is ADT’s Extended Limited Warranty. 36-month monitoring contract required from ADT Pulse Remote: $52.99 per month, ($1,907.64), ADT Pulse Video: $58.99 per month, ($2,123.64), ADT Pulse Home Control with Video: $59.99 per month, ($2,159.64), including Quality Service Plan (QSP). Additional charges may apply in areas that require guard response service for municipal alarm verification. Prices subject to change. Prices may vary by market. Some insurance companies offer discounts on Homeowner’s Insurance. Please consult your insurance company. Local permit fees may be required. Satisfactory credit history required. Additional monitoring fees required for some services. Photos are for illustrative purposes only and may not reflect the exact product/service actually provided.

Last Updated on January 1, 2020 by

Protect America vs ADT was last modified: January 1st, 2020 by

Pin It on Pinterest

Share This